Merchants Eye — Payments & Ecommerce News

AI Boosts Chargeback Win Rates to 38% but Full Automation Lags at 11%, Chargeflow Finds

By Lauren Towner · 16 November 2026

In brief: Chargeflow and Juniper Research find that AI boosts merchant chargeback win rates to 38%, though 89% of businesses have yet to fully automate their dispute processes.

Key facts
AI Win Rate38%
Automation Rate11%
Survey Size121 enterprise merchants
Friendly Fraud Impact25%+ of chargebacks for 43% of merchants
Press Release: AI Boosts Chargeback Win Rates to 38% but Full Automation Lags at 11%, Chargeflow Finds | Featured Image by FF News

A new report from Chargeflow and Juniper Research reveals that while 80% of enterprise merchants have integrated AI into their chargeback management, only 11% have achieved full automation. This disconnect leaves merchants fighting a fraction of eligible disputes, even as chargeback volumes rise for 65% of businesses across the U.S. and U.K.

What was announced

The report, "The State of Chargeback Management: How AI Is Reshaping Performance," surveyed 121 enterprise merchants to quantify the impact of artificial intelligence on dispute resolution. The findings show a clear performance gap: merchants utilizing AI win a median of 38% of the chargebacks they dispute, compared to just 27.75% for those relying on manual processes. Despite this higher win rate, the median merchant in both groups still only disputes and wins 6.65% of their total eligible chargebacks.

The research highlights that 43% of merchants believe "friendly fraud" accounts for more than a quarter of their total chargebacks. This contributes to a significant financial burden, with nearly half of respondents estimating the annual cost of chargebacks at between 0.5% and 1% of their total revenue. Pressure is mounting as nine in 10 merchants who saw chargeback growth reported increases of 10% or more over the last 18 months.

Seasonal data from the Chargeflow Data Lab, which analyzed 3 million disputes, indicates that "order never arrived" claims spike to 34.7% during the Black Friday to Cyber Monday window, up from a 19.9% baseline. To justify further AI investment, 69% of merchants stated they require a tool to lift their win rate by at least 11 percentage points. Currently, AI users report a 10.25-point advantage, narrowly missing the enterprise expectation for adoption. When selecting providers, 72% of merchants prioritized data quality and 70% cited security and compliance as critical factors.

The companies involved

Chargeflow is an AI-driven chargeback management platform designed to help merchants recover lost revenue through automated dispute resolution. The platform is currently used by more than 20,000 merchants and focuses on utilizing deep data science to streamline the recovery process. The company recently expanded its analytical capabilities with the launch of the Chargeflow Data Lab in October 2026, which provides insights into dispute trends and fraud patterns across millions of transactions.

Juniper Research is a specialist market research firm providing analysis and forecasting for the global high-tech communications and fintech sectors. Based in the United Kingdom, the firm is a prominent voice in the payments industry, frequently recognized for its Future Digital Awards which evaluate innovation in digital banking and commerce. Juniper Research provides data-driven insights that are widely used by enterprise organizations to benchmark technology adoption and assess market shifts in the U.S. and European financial landscapes.

What FF News has reported before

FF News has consistently tracked the intersection of AI and merchant protection. In October 2026, we reported that Chargeflow Unveils Prevent 2.0 to Combat Surge in Black Friday 'Item Not Received' Fraud, which addressed the specific seasonal spikes mentioned in the current report. We have also covered the broader industry recognition of the research firm's work, such as when G+D Wins Three Honours at the Juniper Research Future Digital Awards in 2025. Furthermore, the move toward automated recovery was highlighted in our coverage of how Findustry AI and Maverick Payments Partner to Triple Chargeback Win Rates via AI Automation, signaling a broader market shift toward autonomous dispute handling.

What this means

The industry is currently stuck in a "halfway house" of automation. While AI is demonstrably improving the quality of individual dispute rebuttals, the fact that both AI users and non-users contest the same low share of eligible cases suggests a lack of trust in autonomous decision-making. For fintech providers, the challenge is no longer just proving that AI can write a better defense, but proving it can safely decide which battles to fight without human intervention. As friendly fraud continues to erode margins, the pressure is on vendors to close the performance gap that currently prevents widespread, fully automated enterprise adoption.

Frequently asked questions

How much does AI improve chargeback win rates?

According to the Chargeflow and Juniper Research report, merchants using AI achieve a median win rate of 38% on disputed chargebacks. This is a significant improvement over the 27.75% win rate reported by merchants who do not use AI tools.

Why is chargeback automation still low among merchants?

While 80% of merchants use AI in their workflows, only 11% have fully automated the process. This is because most businesses currently use AI to assist manual processes, where humans still decide which specific disputes to file rather than letting the software handle the end-to-end decision-making.

What is the main cause of chargebacks during the holidays?

Data from Chargeflow shows that during the Black Friday to Cyber Monday period, 'order never arrived' claims account for 34.7% of disputes, up from 19.9% in a normal week. Interestingly, traditional fraud claims actually decrease during this peak period.

About the companies

Juniper Research

Website · 32 stories and 1 video interview on FF News since 2021

Previously on FF News:

Chargeflow

Website · 3 stories on FF News since 2025

Previously on FF News:

Companies in this story: Juniper Research, Chargeflow

People in this story: Dan Moshkovich, Nick Maynard

More from News